Canadian Steelmakers Warn China Deal Undermines Crackdown on Cheap Imports
Canadian steel producers say the new trade deal struck between Ottawa and Beijing on Tuesday undermines the fight against cheap steel imports, even as the pact provides relief to other industries impacted by Chinese tariffs.
The agreement, which extends some tariff-relief measures agreed to by Prime Minister Mark Carney and Chinese President Xi Jinping in January, will see Ottawa maintain its ongoing tariff relief measures for certain Chinese steel and aluminum products.
In return, China said it will remove 25-per-cent tariffs on $400 million of Canadian exports, including some pork and seafood.
The extended tariff remission comes after steelmaker Stelco announced in September it was laying off up to 500 employees, citing Donald Trump’s tariffs on Canadian steel products and what it called “the continued flood” of cheap foreign steel imports into Canada. Just last week, 175 Stelco workers were called back to work.
Blair Dickerson, president of the Canadian Steel Producers Association, said the deal has “jeopardized” progress made in Canada to reduce Chinese steel imports. While Dickerson said he understands the federal government is working to advance trade with China, opening the Canadian market up to Chinese steel imports will lessen the “level playing field” in the domestic industry.
The United Steelworkers (USW), which represents more than 225,000 members, added that Chinese-produced steel often undercuts the same products made domestically.
Guio Jacinto, the head of research for USW, said he is concerned with what he called Carney’s “pattern” of giving China tariff relief.
“The more concessions that we give to Chinese steel, the more that we undermine the protections that we’ve built into the Canadian market to protect it from Chinese steel.”
Steelmakers are justified in worrying about the dumping of foreign steel, said Drew Fagan, a professor of public policy at the University of Toronto, but he isn’t convinced the deal will have a significant impact on Canada’s steel industry.
“It’s kind of … small potatoes in the context of the bilateral relationship,” said Fagan. “I don’t know … whether the steel producers here should see (the deal) as potential competition, or should see it as the government sees it, which is an opening to China in circumstances where they’re not going to compete with Canadian steelmakers.”
As long as the federal government adequately polices and ensures Chinese steel entering the country adheres to the remission exemptions in place, it should be able to prevent dumping, he added.
Meanwhile, Canadian pork producers say Ottawa’s deal with China is worth celebrating.
Bruce Hudson, a farmer in Kinburn and board member of Ontario Pork (representing around 1,900 farms), said the agreement “renews faith in the (trade) system.” It also gives pork farmers and producers “assurance” that they will have a market for their goods after being hit by the Chinese tariffs, he said.
Pork exports to China dropped from $469 million in 2024 to $354 million in 2025 once additional Chinese tariffs on the product were introduced, said Kyle Larkin, president of the Canadian Meat Council.
Before Tuesday’s trade announcement, Canadian pork exports to China were on track to account for $250 million in 2026, Larkin added.
The move from the Carney government is “a great first step,” but more needs to be done to address the “erosion of market share” the Canadian pork industry has experienced in China, said Larkin, pointing toward tariffs on Canadian pork offal.
“China is almost the only market and certainly the largest market for pork offal in the world,” he said. “Right now, most pork processors are still sending their offal to China but they’re sending it at a loss.”
While there is “lots of opportunity” for Canada in trading with Asian countries like China, said U of T’s Fagan, Ottawa can’t take its attention away from its largest trade partner: the U.S.
“There’s no replacement for the U.S. market for Canada. There never will be.”
This article was first reported by The Canadian Press






